Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 3, Spearymintal Choco Chip Cookies

The journey to these simple-to-make munchies started out with a discussion about chocolate mint cookies. I meandered to researching mint flavoring and food coloring for mintifying chocolate chip cookies. I wanted them have the color, taste, and chippy looks of mint chocolate chip ice cream, but avoid overdosing.

"Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 1, Sweetish Thoughts" describes my initial journey towards my cooky recipe. It started out with a friend's recommendation for a minty iced chocolate cooky. I got to thinking about similar cookies, then about other sweet, minty yummies. I wondered about mint flavorings, of which I included some info.

"Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 2, Nose 4 Mints N Chips" describes my deeper dive into making a mint chocolate chip cooky, greenish to resemble mint chocolate ice cream. As I would add food coloring and extract, I wondered about their shelf lives. I pointed to various recipes, calculating dough weights for inferring appropriate amounts to use. The toll house mini-chip recipe ingredients help me conclude reasonable amount of chips to use.

My ingredients for these cookies are a box of yellow cake mix, 1/3 cup of oil, 2 eggs, 5 drops of blue food coloring, 3/4 teaspoon of mint extract, and a 10-ounce bag of mini chocolate chips. For saving time and elbow grease in mixing up this dense cooky dough, I used my tilt-head stand mixer. I mixed the liquid ingredients with the balloon whisk, then switched to the flat beater paddle to add the cake mix, then the chips. I doled the dough portions onto a baking pan using a measuring spoon and rubber spatula.

Ingredients

• 1 box of yellow cake mix
• 1/3 cup of oil
• 2 eggs
• 5 drops of blue food coloring
• 3/4 teaspoon of mint extract
• 10-ounce bag of mini chocolate chips

Process (using pastry blender or mixer for combining)

1. Preheat the oven to 350.
2. Mix oil, eggs, mint extract, and food coloring in a large bowl. (I tend to break each egg separately into the bowl before adding the other wet ingredients.)
3. Mix in the cake mix.
4. Fold in the chips.
5. Dole out tablespoons of dough onto pan, leaving ~1" margins for baking expansion. (I use the measuring spoon with rubber spatula method.)
6. Bake each batch for ~ 10 minutes, checking for browning at edges.
7. Cool for ~ 2 minutes before using cooky spatula to transfer them onto cooling rack(s).

I preheated the oven to 350 for about 10 minutes while I doled the dough portions onto a baking pan, between level and rounded tablespoons. Baking time was ~ 10 minutes, about the time cooky edges became slightly brown.  YMMV for amount of time, especially if your parcel out bigger dough dollops than mine. BTW, with bigger dollops, you should allow bigger margins and increase baking time.

Newish to Cooky-making Process?

Visit step-by-step details at "Minty Choco Chip Cake Mix Cookies" (w/images) and "EZ Mini M&M Confetti Cookies" (narrated video, article w/images).

My baker's basic "pre-flight" suggestions:

• Have plenty of food-preparation surface(s).
• Acquire and line up all your ingredients.
• Line up all your implements (bowls, cooky pans, measuring cups/spoons, etc.)
• Remember to preheat the oven.

For additional help, the web and YouTube are LOADED with cooky recipes and advice. If you want the easiest way to step into cooky baking, start with refrigerated cooky pellets (located near refrigerated biscuits).

Cooky Stats

Raw ingredients weight and the chips: ~35 ounces
Yield: 51 ~2/1/2" diameter cookies (24 for 1st pan, 27 for 2nd pan)
Calories: 78 each (3990/51)
 (cake mix powder, 1800, chips, 1400; oil, 650; eggs, 140 -> 3990)

Post-recipe Notes

• The amount of 3/4 teaspoon mint extract seemed reasonable.
• Baked color was less green than I hoped for, some color interference because of slight browning, maybe. Might have been OK to use 7 drops of color instead of 5.
• Weight evaporation from baking was about 2 1/2 ounces.

---

Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 1, Sweetish Thoughts
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 2, Nose 4 Mints N Chips
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 3, Spearymintal Choco Chip Cookies
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 4, Choco Unadorned/Coated Minty Cookies
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 5, Choco Minty Sandwich Cookies

Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 1, Sweetish Thoughts

I recently tried some chocolate-covered mint chocolate cookies, Fudge Mint Cookies (Back to Nature brand), recommended by a friend. Mmmm. Got me to thinking about other minty chocolate cookies. I recalled my supermarket sells Hill Country Fare Fudge Mint Cookies. They're square, minty chocolate with chocolate coating. Decided to look up more similar cookies.

I thought I recalled that Girl Scouts has a minty cooky. Yes! Thin Mints, tersely described in "Meet the Cookies".

The Google results for "girl scout cookies mint chocolate" yielded not only a pointer to the Girl Scouts Thin Mints info, but also loads of pointers to DIY recipes.

All three brands of minty chocolatey cookies, besides sharing characteristics of minty cooky coated with chocolate icing, use peppermint oil. I wondered how that differed from peppermint extract.

Contrasting Peppermint Oil and Extract

"What Is the Difference Between Peppermint Oil & Peppermint Extract?" explains:

The fundamental difference is that peppermint oil is made of pure peppermint, while peppermint extract is essentially a flavored solution—a little peppermint and a lot of something else.

Peppermint oil is the pure, concentrated oil—known as an essential oil—derived from the stems and leaves of the peppermint plant. … An extract is a mixture of an essential oil and a medium—usually alcohol—that helps carry the flavor. … Never ingest pure peppermint oil, which can be toxic in large doses.

Hmm, my bottle of "McCormick® Pure Mint Extract" lists both spearmint and peppermint oils, along with water and 89% alcohol. Speaking of peppermint and spearmint, …

Contrasting Peppermint and Spearmint

From Taste of Home's "What’s the Difference Between Peppermint and Spearmint?":

Peppermint is an incredibly pungent—almost spicy—herb. … And though peppermint is perhaps the better known of the two, it’s actually a natural hybrid of spearmint and water mint. … much more potent than its counterpart. Because peppermint is a mix of two types of mint, it contains a higher content of menthol (40% as opposed to spearmint’s 0.5%).

From Chowhound's "What Is the Difference Between Spearmint and Peppermint?":

Spearmint, containing less than 1% menthol is the far more delicate with a subtly sweet profile, and thus often found in savory dishes; much less likely to overpower other herbs and spices. … peppermint is actually a hybrid of spearmint and water mint. At 40% menthol, it is the surly, punchy and powerful member of the Metha family, and the intensity of it’s “minty” flavor borders on spiciness, earning it a fitting name.

Both Taste of Home and Chowhound sites contain expansive explanations and also links to recipes that use either kind of mint.

Other Sweetish Scent o' Mintal Thoughts

My mind meandered to mint flavored sweets. Hmm, Junior Mints, Peppermint Patties, Andes Mint candies, grasshopper pie, mint chocolate chip ice cream, …

I also thought about articles I'd written that contained mint: Minty Choco Chip Pudding and Minty Choco Chip Cake Mix Cookies

My mind started percolating about another cooky recipe that would integrate yellow cake mix, mini chocolate chips, mint extract, and blue food coloring. This cooky should resemble mint chocolate chip ice cream. I needed to confidently determine the amount of extract and food coloring to use.

---

Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 1, Sweetish Thoughts
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 2, Nose 4 Mints N Chips
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 3, Spearymintal Choco Chip Cookies
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 4, Choco Unadorned/Coated Minty Cookies
Scent o' mintal Journey, Part 5, Choco Minty Sandwich Cookies

Minty Choco Chip Pudding

Look ma, no cooking! Just combine, whisk, stir, and pour ingredients into cups. Ready to eat within minutes. Reasonably lo-cal at a smidge over 200 calories each container.

The idea for the flavor came from a recipe for mint soft-serve ice cream that's in page 20 of the Cuisinart Instruction Booklet (for soft-serve ice cream maker). Having tried the recipe and stirring in grated Wilton Dark Cocoa Mint Candy Melts, I figured the flavors can transfer to a pudding recipe. The ingredients for the ice cream are as follows:

1 cup whole milk, well chilled
¾ cup granulated sugar
2 cups heavy cream, well chilled
1 teaspoon mint extract (may use peppermint or spearmint)
4-5 drops green or pink food coloring

The boxed instant vanilla pudding, which I had on hand, listed the following ingredients for the normal recipe:

1 package instant pudding powder
2 cups of milk [Whisk into pudding powder for 2 minutes.]

In assessing suitable amounts of additions, I considered the following factors:

• The pudding fluids amounted to 2/3 of the ice cream ingredients.
• The ice cream contains lots of air, thus, spreading out mint flavoring by volume.
• The pudding powder already contains sugar.

My pixstrip shows the implements I used (YMMV), the ingredients, and the cups of pudding.
Ingredients

• 1 package instant pudding powder
• 2 cups of nonfat milk
• 1/2 teaspoon spearmint extract
• 4 drops green food coloring
• 2 ounces grated Wilton Dark Cocoa Mint Candy Melts, replaceable with chocolate chips, minty or otherwise

Instructions

1. Whisk the powder and milk for two minutes.
2. Add the extract.
3. Add the food coloring, one drop at a time. More on that later.
4. Stir in the grated candy. Otherwise, you can add Hershey's or Nestle mint chocolate chips, which you might find either at your supermarket.
5. Pour into 4 containers. Sprinkle some candies or chips on top if you like. Eat now or store in fridge for consumption later.

Post-Recipe Thoughts
Good that I guessed right to not put in a whole teaspoon of the extract. As for the food coloring, I wish I had thought earlier to try the blue food coloring, a drap at a time, as the pudding started out vanilla yellowy. Y'know, blue and yellow make green. Oh, well, next time.

I stirred in candy melts, which I had grated and stored in the fridge awhile back. I did experiment with a few regular-sized chocolate chips for bouyancy. I spooned a very small sample of the mixed pudding into a paper cup and stirred in the chips. The pudding had thickened up enough during whisking so that the chips did not sink to the bottom. (Yay!)

---

A similar but different pudding recipe: "Really Quick Mixed-flavor Pudding"